QUOTE (antabaka84 @ Dec 30 2008, 11:37 PM) I am surprised this thread is so short for such a good series!!
I'd like to here what more people thought of Melodies
I
Maybe everyone here was too speechless from watching the series to comment about anything.
But really, it's nothing new. Both seasons of Hidamari Sketch (ironically another Shaft production) also got very little posts despite them being two of the better anime in their respective seasons and years. Some series just get more attention.
That said, I actually liked the first season better. Memories was new and fresh, had more mystery to it, and was an excellent introduction which had a great plot. With Melodies, on the other hand, we already knew some about the series, so most of the mystery had evaporated, but the drama was still palpable, especially the latter part of the series with Yuko and Yu's past gradually revealed.
Despite that, I still greatly enjoyed Melodies, especially the first episode with the overly simple scene with Mizuki and Kuze in his house just talking. What we saw of Yuko's life was very depressing to watch, from her losing her parents in the earthquake, to having that horrible life with her "brother", and then ultimately dying on Christmas because of a senseless car crash. Her reunion with Yu was very touching, and brought some more meaning to the rest of Memories and Melodies.
Overall, the series was very good, and has cemented my love for Shaft, they having animated three of the best series in the past two years: Hidamari Sketch, ef, and Sayonara Zetsubou Sensei. I believe that if ef had been animated by any other conventional animation studio, it wouldn't even have been half as good.