Jump to content


Photo

Anime Debate


  • Please log in to reply
52 replies to this topic

#41 Barbobot

Barbobot

    -the Pirate King

  • Fansub TV Team
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 4328 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Boston, MA (college); Randolph, NJ (hometown)
  • Interests:Barbobot's Anime List:
    http://myanimelist.net/animelist/Barbobot

    www.animecalendar.net

Posted 26 August 2009 - 06:37 PM

I'm sure though if you are a person who doesn't mind dubs or are fond of them there'd be more of an incentive. I know recently I've grown to like dubs a fair amount for some shows. I just watched the Darker than Black dub and it's fairly well done. Baccano and RomeoxJuliet both have great dubs that actually add a bit more to the show that japanese really can't. Though at the same time I realize that there is a large portion of the fansub consuming community that goes "ewwwww dub. Keep away. Burn at the stake!" which is a bit unfortunate.
They do need to make their subs a bit better on the eyes though. I remember that topic coming up at the fansubber Otakon panel that ANN has on their video section. Nothing special is needed. Just give me some plain, clean white letters with a black outline so they can be clearly read. That's all I need to be happy with the shows I wouldn't want to watch dubbed.

@Hiroyuki
As for the convenience thing, well I guess for me that just doesn't really count. I have just about all my anime on externals that I don't keep attached to my computer as I have a laptop I move around quite often. Thus the spontaneity is gone cause I either have to go get my external, plug it into my computer, and hook my computer to my TV if I want to watch it on that. Or get the DVD out, put it in my PS3 for the TV or my computer. Though I figure a fair amount of people don't have this problem as they might not move their laptop around much or just have a desktop and leave things hooked up.

#42 pjcountach

pjcountach

    -chi

  • Kouhais
  • Pip
  • 38 posts
  • Interests:Anime for one, Aquarium fish, Lego, Italian Cars, Muscle cars. Fantasy and Science fiction,

Posted 26 August 2009 - 10:53 PM

@ Hiroyuki
I actually like the menus and...elusive extras. I usually check out the trailers, I've found some excellent shows that way, and then can choose between sub or dub.
I prefer to watch sub, but I've realized that quite a few of the more recent dubs are actually quite good...friends made me do it dry.gif

Also, unlike some people with terabytes of space, I have a whopping 40 Gigs free,(well, not anymore), so I eagerly watch for new licenses on the downloaded shows so I can buy it and clear space for the next show.
---I also have something of a book collector complex. Seeing the dvd box art on my shelf makes me happy, especially because I don't have to memorize a list, I can just show it off. or quickly remember what I wanted to watch and reach for it without waiting for my computer to warm up...yes, it runs slow.

In the end I treat fansubs like pre-license marketing, I read the synopsis, watch the show, and buy series I finish.
---alternatively I read reviews at Themanime and make an educated guess with my wallet.


I think something should go here...

#43 NeoScott

NeoScott

    -san

  • Kouhais
  • PipPipPip
  • 212 posts
  • Location:Canada

Posted 31 August 2009 - 03:09 AM

I buy the anime I love and I'll buy anime i like when it comes in a complete season, at a good price.

Cost really is an issue with me, but i belive some companys deserve my money.

I'll be buying eden of the east, and All of Sayonara Zetsubou Sensei when they come out in canada.

There a ton of anime i'll wait for the series to come out, i wont go into detail.

I would rather they realse the DVD with only subs, I HATE Dubs, Have you ever seen Teknoman? That anime was so poorly dubbed, the voices sucked, and I COULD HEAR THAT THEY HATED THERE JOBS. sad to say i paid $20 cnd to find a new reason to kill everyone.

anyways, I do buy anime only for the eps, I don't care for speical features. I really can't care about art work and music videos and printable stickers when the sticker sheet will cost me more then the dvd did. And really, WHY do I need PRINTABLE ANYTHING off a dvd? I have the internet, I can google ANYTHING I want.


QUOTE

Also, unlike some people with terabytes of space, I have a whopping 40 Gigs free,(well, not anymore), so I eagerly watch for new licenses on the downloaded shows so I can buy it and clear space for the next show. 


Can I suggest you buy some blank dvd's?
May you love one forever.

Anime I've seen(Updated):

.hack//Sign
Afro Samurai
Ah! My Goddess
Akane-iro ni Somaru Saka
Akira
Aoi Hana
Asu no Yoichi
Asura Cryin'
Baccano!
Bakemonogatari
BECK: Mongolian Chop Squad
Black Lagoon
Blood +
Blue Drop
Candy Boy
Cannan
Chaos Head
Chobits
Chrome Shelled Regios
D.N.Angel
Da Capo
Darker Than Black
Death Note
Desert Punk
Detriot Metal City
Devil May Cry
Eden of the East
EF A Tale of Melodies
EF A Tale of Memories
Elfen lied
Escaflowne
Eureka 7
Eve no Jikan
Full Metal Panic! 1/2/3
Ghost in the Shell: Stand Alone Complex/2nd GIG
Girls Bravo
Gravitation
Gundamn Wing
Gungrave
H2O - foot prints in the sand
Hellsing
His And Her Circumstances
Ichigo 100%
Inukami!
InuYasha
Itazura na Kiss
Kampfer
Kanamemo
Kannagi
Kannagi
Kanokon
Kashimashi Girl Meets Girl
Kimi Ga Nozomu Eien
Kimikiss
Kiss x sis
Knights of the Zodiac
Kodomo No Jikan
Koihime Musou
K-on
Ladies Vs Bulters
Lovley complex
Macademi Wasshoi
Macross Frontier
Maid Guy
Maria Holic
Maria Holic
Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya I/II
Moetan
Myself yourSelf
Negima!: Magister Negi Magi
Neon Genesis Evangelion
Nodame Cantabile
Nodame Cantabile: Paris Chapter
Nogizaka haruka no himitsu
Omamori Himari
Pet Shop of Horror
Please Teacher
Princess lover
Queen's Blade
R.O.D the TV
Roario Vamprie I/IIS
Sasameki Koto
Sayonara Zetsubou Sensei 1/2/2.5/3
School days
Sekirei
Seto no Hanayome
Shinkyoku Soukai Polyphonica Crimson S
Sono Hanabira ni Kuchizuke wo Anata wo Sukina Shiawase
Sora no Otoshimono
spice and wolf I/II
Strawberry panic
Strike Witches
toheart
Toradora
Trigun
True Tears
valkyria chronicles
Venture brothers 1/2/3
X:Movie
Zero no Tsukaima

#44 king of cole

king of cole
  • Kouhais
  • 1 posts

Posted 10 February 2010 - 11:55 PM

I really don't understand why torrents are illigal, (other than the courts and law) i use torrents to watch my piss poor quality anime just months after its first release, it takes up to 4 years for them to produce one dvd in english, i think i will watch the fansubed till i get the OFFICAL set, Dose anyone agree?

i have downloaded ikki tousan, neon genesis, maburaho, chobots, X TV, GITS, cowboy bebop and Scryed and deleated them when i got the entire sets, now i burn copies and use them so i don't damage my hard earned collection.
but even coping your own dvds for your own privet use is illigal too, GOOD DAMN LAW SYSTEM, they make it out that your a criminal just by enjoying your self.
the gov is cruppted and nixon must be up to his arsehole in brinstone right about now.

Edited by king of cole, 11 February 2010 - 12:14 AM.


#45 Dalriada

Dalriada

    -dono

  • Sempais
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 686 posts

Posted 11 February 2010 - 05:54 PM

QUOTE
I really don't understand why torrents are illigal, (other than the courts and law)


Other than the courts and law, nothing is illegal.
It's the definition of 'illegal'. wink.gif


QUOTE
i have downloaded ikki tousan, neon genesis, maburaho, chobots, X TV, GITS, cowboy bebop and Scryed and deleated them when i got the entire sets, now i burn copies and use them so i don't damage my hard earned collection.


The question is : do you buy everything you download ?

Some people will say "I download animes, and then I buy the good ones", but there's two problems :
-What if you (a generic you, not a 'you' you) are very choosy ? You watch 30 animes series per year, and you buy only one ? There's a problem.
-Why are you watching the bad ones ? They are bad, you acknowledge it since you don't buy them, and yet you watch them ? Have you a problem ?

Otherwise, I agree with you on the need of a private copy. But as often, legitimate uses are screwed because of illegitimate ones.
A foolish consistency is the hobgoblin of little minds, adored by little statesmen and philosophers and divines.
Ralph Waldo Emerson

#46 warita200

warita200

    -RETIRED-

  • Retired
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 2932 posts
  • Interests:For those who care and would like to contact me at some point, I can be found on Anime-Suki under the user name: warita (only warita without the 200) :)<br><br>The email that I have on FTV wont work, because I changed accounts a few months ago.

Posted 11 February 2010 - 07:41 PM

QUOTE (Dalriada @ Feb 11 2010, 11:54 AM)

The question is : do you buy everything you download ?

Some people will say "I download animes, and then I buy the good ones", but there's two problems :
-What if you (a generic you, not a 'you' you) are very choosy ? You watch 30 animes series per year, and you buy only one ? There's a problem.
-Why are you watching the bad ones ? They are bad, you acknowledge it since you don't buy them, and yet you watch them ? Have you a problem ?


on the other hand, why should I buy dozens of animes, that are crappy? I am very picky and I download more than I ever buy. Thats just how it goes. I gladly support the studios, that produced something worthy buying and refuse to pay for something, that isnt good enough. Fortunately the internet allows me to check the animes out before spending money. biggrin.gif As for the argument, that I dont pay for the "bad" animes I am watching..... well, this doesnt actually do any harm to the studio that produced the anime. Because the anime is already produced and I am not going to buy so or so. To the studio it makes no difference in the end, whether I watch it or not, coz there is no money coming from me either way.

#47 Dalriada

Dalriada

    -dono

  • Sempais
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 686 posts

Posted 12 February 2010 - 08:34 AM

QUOTE
on the other hand, why should I buy dozens of animes, that are crappy?


But they are crappy ! Why do you watch them ? Are you masochist ?

Usually, this argument is hypocritical.
It uses two scales of quality : on the one hand, animes that are good enough to be watched and on the other hand those that are good enough to be bought. Which leads to some situations like "I watch five hours of animes per weeks, and I buy the good ones. How many animes are good enough ? I don't know, 3 or 4 since I've begun watching animes".
It's hypocritical, because you just have to watch them and say "not good enough" everytime (or almost everytime, you still need a cheap alibi).

A foolish consistency is the hobgoblin of little minds, adored by little statesmen and philosophers and divines.
Ralph Waldo Emerson

#48 monsta

monsta

    -the bee's knees

  • Retired
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 2252 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:London, England

Posted 20 February 2010 - 11:14 PM

QUOTE (Dalriada @ Feb 12 2010, 09:34 AM)
Usually, this argument is hypocritical.
It uses two scales of quality : on the one hand, animes that are good enough to be watched and on the other hand those that are good enough to be bought. Which leads to some situations like "I watch five hours of animes per weeks, and I buy the good ones. How many animes are good enough ? I don't know, 3 or 4 since I've begun watching animes".
It's hypocritical, because you just have to watch them and say "not good enough" everytime (or almost everytime, you still need a cheap alibi).

While what you say is true and can apply to many forms of media in general (be it music, films or games etc) I think we need to make a distinction with anime. The reason I say this is because anime is not readily available, at least less so than other media.

If I want to test music or films to see whether it worth buying I listen to the radio or watch TV. It is all free and it is not illegal yet it is a cheap way of testing the product for "free" before making the final purchase. There are plenty of things that are only worth trying out once and not everything is worth buying. So while you could argue it is hypocritical it is a fact of life, especially if ones disposal income is more limited (which is more relevant in this current economic climate).

Now I am not saying that downloading anime or watching illegal streams will have no effect on demand (downloading does have an effect). Whether it is positive or negative is another debate altogether. One thing should be noted however; the less money we spend on a product the more prepared we are to accept mediocre work. If I pay 50 cents for an anime episode I will have a lower expectation on its quality and will watch more mediocre series. Conversely, if the price is raised then my expectation of quality will increase. Seeing as anime is generally perceived as over-priced (compared to other media such as films/TV series) then it stands to reason that anime series must be considerably better than other media to justify its high price, at least that is the expectation the consumer will have. So it shouldn't be surprising if overall demand is lower as people will expect more that much more. A premium product demands premium quality otherwise there will be no sale.

#49 Dalriada

Dalriada

    -dono

  • Sempais
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 686 posts

Posted 22 February 2010 - 06:02 PM

QUOTE
While what you say is true and can apply to many forms of media in general (be it music, films or games etc) I think we need to make a distinction with anime. The reason I say this is because anime is not readily available, at least less so than other media.


How many people here read the fan-translated chapters of One Piece, Naruto or Bleach (or watch the animes) ?

I agree with your argument (although there another way to make an opinion on a work : reading reviews or critics), but I still think it's mainly a cheap alibi (a bit more expensive than before, but still cheap) because the animes and mangas that are most often 'pirated' are the most successful and the most famous, i.e. those who will be quickly translated in english (or french, for me) by an official editor.
A foolish consistency is the hobgoblin of little minds, adored by little statesmen and philosophers and divines.
Ralph Waldo Emerson

#50 warita200

warita200

    -RETIRED-

  • Retired
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 2932 posts
  • Interests:For those who care and would like to contact me at some point, I can be found on Anime-Suki under the user name: warita (only warita without the 200) :)<br><br>The email that I have on FTV wont work, because I changed accounts a few months ago.

Posted 22 February 2010 - 06:40 PM

QUOTE (Dalriada @ Feb 12 2010, 02:34 AM)

But they are crappy ! Why do you watch them ? Are you masochist ?


I dont watch them, thats the point. I want to check the animes out, before I buy them. And for the few I watch and dont buy them, well, thats life!!!!!

And as for the reviews.... if I would rely on that, I wouldnt have watched tons of good animes, because the reviews made the anime sound bad and besides, the opinions are influenced by the subjective opinion of the writer. At the same time I have read numerous times wonderfull plot descriptions and reviews about animes, that suck big time. No way I can rely on that.

#51 warita200

warita200

    -RETIRED-

  • Retired
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 2932 posts
  • Interests:For those who care and would like to contact me at some point, I can be found on Anime-Suki under the user name: warita (only warita without the 200) :)<br><br>The email that I have on FTV wont work, because I changed accounts a few months ago.

Posted 27 June 2010 - 08:50 AM

I decided to refresh this thread with something I have noticed lately.

A little background info on my situation: my dorm has banned torrent clients so I had to say good bye to torrent downloading..... it is hard... yeahh. But internet offers other possibilities, albeit not as comfortable ones as torrents. I mean, there is nothing easier than to search isohunt or tokyotosho, add it to your client and just wait for it to be finished, right?

Now I have to spend considerable time looking for direct downloading of my anime or resort to crappy quality of crunchy roll and similar places. Now, I dont mind watching my anime online, but I want to keep some animes for later. I dont download much and never did, but I do have some favourites and I want to keep those. Unfortunately, most of my favs are licenced, right? So that rules FTV out and many other places.

So, that leads me to what I wanted to say in the first place. I discovered few anime sites, that offer direct downloading.... but you got to be a premium member.... meaning, you have to pay ~5$ per months or buy a year membership..... either way, it left me wondering, how exactly this works.

Basically, offering anime for downloading is already balancing at the line of illegality itself. But for money? I think that crosses the line for sure. I think it works like this..... some dude has an awesome collection of animes, he joins with some other friends who also have libraries of their own, they open a site for direct downloading. But while at it, why not make some bucks from it too? I suppose running a site like this doesnt come for free..... but hey, Daft doesnt ask for money, right? So, they are actually making profits.

Now, considering the other posts I have written in this thread, maybe you wonder about my sudden change of heart.... but somehow the audacity of the said sites makes me angry.

Also, one of the sites I had a closer look at was offering:

1 months: 5$
1 year: 35$

This reminded me of rapidshare, that asks fpr 6,99$ per month and I bet the quality of service is considerably higher, right? I mean, you can download all kinds of things from rapidshare at considerably higher speeds too, but an anime site has only anime and there is only that much of interest. Oo Isnt that a little expensive for what you get?

#52 nijlandp

nijlandp

    -sama

  • Sempais
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 2627 posts
  • Location:the Netherlands
  • Interests:anime, manga, japanese language, football<br>The anime i watched:<br>- Robotech (everything there is)<br>- Thundersub<br>- Transformers<br>- Thundercats<br>- Mask<br>- The real ghostbusters<br>- Visionairies<br>- Akira<br>- Golden Boy<br>- Hand Maid May<br>- Neon Genesis Evangelion<br>- Rozen Maiden (all 3 series)<br>- Cowboy Bebop<br>- Sister Princess<br>- Maburaho<br>- To heart (all)<br>- Card Captor Sakura (movies)<br>- Wind a breath of heart<br>- Midori no Hibi<br>- REC<br>- Tsukuyomi - Moon phase<br>- Ah my goddess (all)<br>- Green Green<br>- Kanon 2002 and 2006<br>- Final Approach<br>- Zero No Tsukaima<br>- Futakoi<br>- Tokimeki <br>- Kekkaishi<br>- One<br>- The melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya<br>- Neon Genesis Evangelion<br>- Saikano<br>- Aishiturize Baby<br>- Kono Nirikukumo itsukushii sekai<br>- Air TV<br>- Pita Ten<br>- Onegai Teacher<br>- Onegai Twins<br>- Karin<br>- Tales of Phantasia<br>- Ichigo 100%<br>- Love Hina<br>- Ai Yori Aoshi (both series)<br>- Hourglass of Summer<br>- Chobits<br>- Elfenlied<br>- Saber Marionette J<br>- Saishi Heiki Kanojo<br>- Da capo<br>- Mahurabo - Heartfull days<br>- Inukami <br>- Bottle fairy<br>- Sola<br>- Ranma 1/2<br>- Sumomo mo momo mo<br>- Today in class 5-2<br>- he is my master<br>- Shakugan no shana<br>- Fate stay night<br>- Zero no tsukaima 2 <br>- School days<br>- Mamotte! lollipop<br>- Mushiuta<br>- Hayate no Gotoku<br>- Lovely complex <br>- Lucky star<br>- Sayonara zetsubou sensei<br>- _summer<br>- Code-e<br>- Nagasarete Airantou<br>- Moetan<br>- Kamichama Karin<br>- Seto no Hanayome<br>- Kaibutsu Oujo<br>- Umisho<br>- Mamorukun ni megami no shukufuku wo!<br>- Clannad<br>- Myself; yourself<br>- Kodomo no jikan<br>- Shugo Chara<br>- Goshuushou-sama ninomiya-kun<br>- prism ark<br>- Fate stay night<br>- Shakugan no shana<br>- ef - a tale of memories<br>- rental magic <br>- kimikiss pure rouge<br>- suteki tantei labyrinth<br>- koharubiyori<br>- higurashi no naku koro ni kai<br>- potemayo <br>- nanatsuiro drops<br>- kakurenbo<br>- chocotto sister<br>- trouble chocolate<br>- hanbun no tsuki ga noboru sora<br>- ichigo mashimaro<br>- mushiuta<br>- puni puni poemi<br>- Eiken<br>- Cosplay complex<br>- Touka Gettan<br>- sister princess<br>- kareshi kanojo no jijou<br>- winter garden<br>- sakura diaries<br>- dokuro<br>- nodame cantabile<br>- exosquad<br>- welcome to the n.h.k.<br>- itsudatte my santa

Posted 27 June 2010 - 08:29 PM

If the site really asks for money for a download it must be over the line of the copyright issues. Hmm, you may be right about getting angry at those sites. They profit from the work of the free fansub groups...How can you ask money for something a volunteer (who him/herself doesn't ask for money) did to help others?
Getting an account at rapidshare would be a better option since those prices really are over the top. It is better to get it from there and if you like it to buy the anime itself.

#53 Ausdoerrt

Ausdoerrt

    -sama

  • Retired
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 3344 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:USA, W&amp;L
  • Interests:Anime =) - esp fantasy, school comedy, fighting;
    All sorts of metal - including Japanese;
    All the Japanese stuff;
    Russian science fiction.

Posted 28 June 2010 - 11:08 AM

If warita's living in the States then getting RS membership is a waste of money, since MU is a lot faster there, and free membership download rules aren't nearly as restrictive as RS either.

I don't have torrent in my dorms either, but Animetake or any other community that makes MU anime mirrors for all the new torrents works just fine. And if you need to DL a lot there's always "happy hour".

And of course don't forget that FTV here also has direct download options, even if the new episodes are uploaded a bit later sometimes, it's another great option that's absolutely free.
<p>monofood.gif<br><a data-ipb='nomediaparse' href='http://www.animenews...r=Ausdoerrt'>My rarely-updated anime list</a></p>




0 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users